Does it even look like natural tanning?

It depends on what kind of spray tan you get/go to, mystic tan has always looked good on me and it is a simply process that can usually be found at tanning salons. lasts for about a week and looks like you just went on vacation. I also have been to a salon where they spray you by hand and in my opinion it wasn't as good! just my opinion tho! good luck on finding what works best for you!

Spray tanning can and does look very natural.  If you have a good spray tanning technician, they should be able to tell you what % would look best on your skin tone. 

http://www.lotions-for-less.com/home.php?cat=271

These are some of the best self tanning products I have found. The key is when spraying yourself to always keep the spray can moving! The Versaspa system in salons is amazing!!

I think it looks good and just like you were in the sun. I just started getting spray tans in the fall and now I don't think i'll go back to regular tnaning.

My best guess would be adore tanning, they have great organic spray tan products and tanning lotion products have a look you will find some useful articles on using tanning products as well http://www.adoretanning.com/

[COMMENT DELETED]

I think spray tanning looks awful, besides, why would you want to deny yourself the health benefits of tanning? UV rays and vitamin D can help fight disease and they can improve your mood. Why would you spray tan? That just seems ridiculous and all about vanity.

---

 Spray Tanning can look very natural depending on the brand of solution you prefer to use.  I use EnvyTan's Temptations line of solutions.  The spray tan is into a golden bronze, sun-kissed color, giving it the appearance of a natural tan.  I had a spa I went to that actually thought it was a natural tan, boy were they shocked when I told them it was a spray tan.